Setting the table on a new Doc Ford's: Captiva VS. Sanibel

Sanibel and Captiva, small neighboring and tropical islands, have never really been in competition.  Collaboration, yes, but not competition.

The reasons to go to either are varied, but each offers a different experience.

The larger of the two, Sanibel Island, is home to Ding Darling Nature Preserve.  It is ringed with bike paths , has two grocery stores and hosts dozens of restaurants.  Captiva is defined by a few things: the village area, proximity to both Gulf and Bay, and the ability to walk to different activities.

Because the two islands, connected by a tiny nearly imperceptible bridge, are quite alike in topicality, and only a couple of minutes drive from one another, it sometimes surprises visitors that there are many observable  differences which often includes pricing, Sanibel being the more affordable of the two.  Generally, the island vacation goer knows in advance if Sanibel or Captiva is the place that they want to be.

But now, within a 15 minute drive or less, there comes a more difficult choice. 

Captiva has opened its own Doc Ford's.  This popular eatery on Rabbit Road on Sanibel has taken up residence in South Seas Plantation, replacing the BBQ eatery, Holy Smoke. 

And this is going to be a tough choice. Do you eat at the dowager Doc Fords on Sanibel or the newbie Doc Fords on Captiva?

Both restaurants will be offering similar menus with identical pricing.  From the feedback we have seen, both casual dining options have great cooks.  For example, we have seen specials posted that ring a most familiar bell, such as Fresh Grilled Grouper over Pork Belly and Shrimp Fried Rice Finished with an Asian Sweet-Ginger Citrus Sauce.  A high yum, yum quotient to be sure, but also one that is available from time to time on Sanibel.

Both restaurants have a sports bar and both draw on the name of Randy Wayne White's most famous character, Doc Ford.

Both are very comfortable places for couples, groups and families.

So, how does one distinguish exactly where they want to go?

We can only see a couple of differences that may help you decide.

The Sanibel Doc Ford's is a much larger place, and on busy night, the probability of getting a table may be better.  In addition, being on the main road of the Island, it is easier accessed.  That said, the Captiva Doc Ford's has outdoor, as well as indoor,  dining.  And the access in South Seas Plantation is quite attractive.

As reviews and experiences roll in, we will be sure to keep you apprised of how the new kid on the block in Captiva is doing.  Let us know your thoughts should you give it a try yourself~!